The last few weeks has seen a welcome return of my interest in the Battle for Normandy in 1944. For the planned recce to the area I knew there would be a lot of research needed even with just focusing on the first two -three days and just the American sector. However I have been pleasantly surprised but just how much material I keep finding that I am looking forward to reading through.
I even managed to find three books at a war-games show that were useful (well two of them are not so much linked to the American involvement but are for a future recce).
It helped that they were all on offer as well and I always struggle to pass up history books that are 50% or less than the RRP.
This was a short update on what I am doing at the moment and will post up some of my research soon.
Showing posts with label conflict. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conflict. Show all posts
Tuesday, 24 February 2015
Thursday, 21 August 2014
The ISIS Problem
Yesterday and today has seen a vast amount of media coverage devoted to the beheading of American Journalist James Foley and the alleged British element of ISIS. While this was indeed shocking is hardly a surprise. After all ISIS or IS has become renowned for their brutal methods and acts.
It is the message regarding nationality which is getting the air time and the talk of extremists returning home to carry out further outrages. While this is a natural concern and one that is very real, it remains to be seen if there will be a new direction from ISIS or if they will inspire more home grown elements. Certainly action by local elements against ISIS forces will keep ISIS focused on the Levant and while this might provide a training ground and actual experience of combat to extremists, it also means that they have to be seen to achieve success if they wish to maintain credibility.
The Royal United Services Institute have published a number of interesting articles related to ISIS and the the issues at hand over the last few days. Here is an article that I was reading earlier very concise and to the point but it is a point well made.
The use of US airpower will increase as a result of this murder and the ante has been upped. It is doubtful if you will see combat troops once again deployed on Iraqi soil but with US airpower bolstering Kurdish forces and hopefully Iraqi military forces ISIS might be pushed back and either destroyed as a credible threat/alternative (which ever way you view it, this would seem unlikely given the nature of the organisation) or diminished to the point where they present a threat but one that is managable by regional elements.
It is the message regarding nationality which is getting the air time and the talk of extremists returning home to carry out further outrages. While this is a natural concern and one that is very real, it remains to be seen if there will be a new direction from ISIS or if they will inspire more home grown elements. Certainly action by local elements against ISIS forces will keep ISIS focused on the Levant and while this might provide a training ground and actual experience of combat to extremists, it also means that they have to be seen to achieve success if they wish to maintain credibility.
The Royal United Services Institute have published a number of interesting articles related to ISIS and the the issues at hand over the last few days. Here is an article that I was reading earlier very concise and to the point but it is a point well made.
The use of US airpower will increase as a result of this murder and the ante has been upped. It is doubtful if you will see combat troops once again deployed on Iraqi soil but with US airpower bolstering Kurdish forces and hopefully Iraqi military forces ISIS might be pushed back and either destroyed as a credible threat/alternative (which ever way you view it, this would seem unlikely given the nature of the organisation) or diminished to the point where they present a threat but one that is managable by regional elements.
Labels:
conflict,
Conflict Diary,
Iraq,
ISIS,
RUSI,
Syria,
UK Armed Forces,
US Armed Forces,
War
Tuesday, 10 December 2013
Marine A - Sergeant Blackman
The identity of Marine A has now been revealed as Sergeant
Alexander Blackman, this in itself has generated a lot of debate as to whether
or not this was the right thing to do. Secondly Sgt Blackman has now been
sentenced to Life with a minimum of ten years to be served. The debate about
the naming and sentence has been very interesting to read and to see the
support that Sgt Blackman actually has. As ever the debate spans the
conventional media as well as social media. The debate seems to focus on the
argument that as he was under a lot of pressure when he committed the act and
events of the tour had taken its toll on Sgt Blackman. Added to this is the
idea that unless you have experienced what Sgt Blackman had been through then
you cannot judge him.
The other side of the coin points out the fallacy of that
statement and the fact that in many ways it is not the man but the action that
is being judged. There is also the recognition that indeed the Sgt was under a
lot of pressure and had witnessed quite a bit on this tour of duty. However as the video shows the Sgt was fully
aware of the actions that he was taking and it was certainly not while under
fire.
One article highlights an interesting point about the camera
footage and the pressures and strains that over ten years of operational
deployments has put on the training in the armed forces. The article points out
the over familiarisation between the Sergeant and the Privates via the use of
the term “mate”. This may seem trivial at first but as the article points out
the enlisted men should be referring to Sgt Blackman as Sergeant or “Sarge” at
the very least. These terms may seem to be interchangeable and an unnecessary criticism
but as the article points out the difference is at the heart of military
discipline.
There is a growing call for his sentence to be halved or
reduced due to mitigating circumstances. Indeed yesterday it was revealed that
an appeal against Sgt Blackman’s conviction was to be launched.
For what it is worth I am on the fence when it comes to the
sentence, I believe that it was right for Sgt Blackman to face trial and for
justice to be seen to be fair. Perhaps the sentence is on the high side, but
the appeal will certainly draw this out. The important thing from all of this
is that it highlights how we (the British people) ask so much of our military
and yet seem to provide the least possible. It is no surprise that a lot of
care once former soldiers have left falls to charities such as Combat Stress,
Help for Heroes and the Royal British Legion. This is where Sgt Blackman has so
far been let down and here is where the argument relating to his mental
wellbeing needs to be taken into account and to hopefully wake our government up
to the fact that more care both before, during and after tours of duty needs to
be in place. The army is certainly not full of soldiers one tour away from
shooting POW’s, however there are a lot of serving and former serving soldiers
that could do would support and advice.
Wednesday, 4 December 2013
Casualty of War
Marine A is due to be sentenced and the resulting media
blitz on this case will begin anew. On Monday the Telegraph website published an
interesting article on the matter of combat in Afghanistan. Written by a
journalist who has embedded with the Royal Marines a number of times, it is not
surprising the view point that Chris Terrill takes. Indeed he writes with a knowledge that a lot of commentators do not have.
I believe that if Marine A is a criminal of war, then he is also a casualty of war.”
This is the key point when it comes to sentencing, yes he has done wrong and justice has to be seen to be done, however it has to fit the crime and not be used as an example to other would be transgressors of the Geneva Convention.
Wednesday, 20 November 2013
Syria and The Continuing Conflict
There was a very interesting article published on the
Guardian website a couple of days ago (the 18th of November 2013). The article
addressed the growing realisation that the war is shifting or has shifted from
a revolution against the government of Assad and is now a full civil war.
The author spends time with three members of a rebel
battalion and speaks at length about how there is no unity and how the Assad
forces are hitting them from the front and the Jihadist forces are effectively
hitting them from behind. It makes for sombre reading as the problems faced are
many and paints a clear picture of the danger that faces Syria. Syria being
consigned to an ongoing struggle between the myriad groups opposing Assad and
the regime. One of the subjects of the article says that this might take 10
years to resolve and for a coherent unified Syria to emerge post Assad. However
if Assad were to fall now then the country would become split in to mini states
of warring tribes, Islamists and
battalions. This would not be a bright future either for Syria or the region. For
a glimpse into the confusing world of factional and ideological identities; the
accidental wrong identification and beheading of a wounded rebel does not bode
well (Article is here).
The article that is the subject of this post does make a very good point when the commander
of a rebel battalion states that for the most part the rebels know only how to
fight and seize areas from the pro government forces. The Jihadists on the
other hand set up governance and a form of stability, this stability is what is
helping the Jihadists and more extreme elements gain ground and importantly
exercise control even after they have moved on.
Without stability and a credible alternative to Assad it is an
uphill struggle for the rebel forces.
The real question is can stability ever exist post Assad and
will there be a credible alternative that is not one controlled by Jihadist
factions?
The conflict has been dragging on and certainly shows no
sign of slowing down despite the potential tipping point over chemical weapons
in the summer. For the Syrian people the future is bleak and likely to involve
instability for some time to come. So far casualties have exceeded 120,000 as
this article points out. The article also confirms the position that the
conflict shows no sign of slowing down.
The comments provided at the end of the Guardian article make for
reading that is both alarming and comical. There are some posts of merit in the comments, however a fair number descend into conspiracy and unsupported accusations leveled at various nations.
Saturday, 16 November 2013
Prisoners of War on the Battlefield
Still image from Helmet Camera footage. Photo Source: Ministry Of Defence/PA
The trial of the three Royal Marines accused of executing a
member of the Taliban has come to a close with two of them being acquitted and
a third known as “Marine A” being found guilty. This has lead to an interesting
debate involving a number of serving and former officers from various services
relating to the sentence “Marine A” should receive. These range from a call for leniency through
to no leniency and “Marine A” facing the full sentence possible as “murder is
still murder”. This Article strikes a good balance in discussing such an emotive issue.
Warfare is never clear cut and the taking of prisoners is always a very dangerous time for all parties involved. There is always the worry that perhaps the enemy combatant is not sincere in their surrender, that perhaps at the first opportunity will seek to harm his captors when there attention is elsewhere.
This case however is one of the more clear cut ones as the enemy combatant in this case was severely wounded and posed no direct threat to the Marines involved. Indeed it seems that this was carried out with malice and with revenge for the casualties suffered by the Marines unit and the displaying of body parts as trophies.
While it has to be remembered that the serving soldiers are under a huge pressure and strain, this does not give them a free card in how they behave. It was an exceptionally foolish thing to do and one that brings the British armed forces and the wider forces that are part of ISAF into disrepute.
Many soldiers,sailors and airmen serve as part of ISAF and this incident involves a very minor percentage, let us hope that it remains this way and cases of this nature will still shock us when they do occur.
Monday, 11 November 2013
11 November 2013
Another year and another remembrance Sunday full of debate relating to the wearing of the Poppy, the ongoing conflict in Afghanistan, foreign policy and the ugly spectre of burning poppies. Each year the debates tend to run along the same lines. Next year will be very interesting with the anniversary of the Great War and the draw down of all forces from Afghanistan. I expect there will be a lot more commentary about what the poppy symbolises, the 'lost generation' and hopefully a lot less relating to Britains foreign policy of the last 12 years.
As we approach the centenary of the outbreak of the Great War the annual Poppy Appeal has become a broader battleground. Parties from both sides of the fence and those with no real interest the political aspects of wearing a poppy have become increasingly vocal.
Last week the national media was full of commentary attacking each view on why the commentator would or would not be wearing a poppy. I think that debate on wearing a poppy is healthy and not something you should stifle even if I disagree with some reasons for not wearing one. The fact that we have a choice to wear a poppy and the fact that we are allowed to decide a reason for wearing one should say a lot about our society. For myself I wear a poppy in remembrance and to support the work of the Royal British Legion. This is especially important given the increase in take up of it’s services over the last ten years due to increased military activity in both Iraq and Afghanistan.
There was a very good article that I read on the website of the Wallstreet Journal. While I knew a little about the Cenotaph and how it was originally meant to only be temporary, the article filled a gap in my knowledge and gave me a better understanding regarding its design and construction.
The article can be found here.
I would also like to advertise a friend’s writing blog as he has written a very short story based on the morning of the 1st of July 1916. He is a budding author so if historical fiction is something that interests you please check it out.
Sunday, 15 September 2013
Lessons From The Last War
I have been reading an article (Lessons From The Last War - Predicting The Next War) today regarding nation’s that
have prepared for future wars based on the previous war. One of the examples
used in the article was the approach of both Germany and France in the lead up
to the campaign in 1940. The article argued that while both nations went down
very different paths, both could be said to have taken lessons from the last
war.
In the case of France it prepared to fight the next war by
the standards of the last war and was tied in to a firepower based doctrine for
attacking.
The Germans on the other hand took the lessons from the last
war to show that a mobile approach to warfare was needed and that the what was
needed was a concentration of armour to force a break through and push for the
enemy rear and center of communications etc.
The part of the article that got me thinking however was how
the author showed that actually both lessons from the last war were applicable
to the war in question. While the German approach worked in part due to the
lack of adequate anti-tank weaponry in appropriate proportions, as the war
progressed and the anti-tank density increased the French lessons became more
applicable to the conduct of the war especially when it came to breaking the
determined German defensive positions in Normandy.
The second example used for the article is the lessons from
the 1967 ‘Six Day War’ between the Israeli Defence Force (IDF) and Egypt and their
application during the war in 1973. Once again the article points out how the
lessons were learned and then applied in each case. The example is concluded that while the IDF
suffered significant casualties especially to its tank formations, it still
emerged victorious. The author also points out that had the IDF taken a
different route as various commentators suggested the casualties might have
been greater and Egyptian gains more permanent due to the loss of mobility.
Israel drew an important lesson from the 1973 war and that was that the IDF was
too small for the wars it was having to fight.
The author concludes the article by making the point that
lessons can be learned from past wars but doctrine should not be fixed on these
lessons as it is very likely that others have also studied previous wars and
drew their own lessons. The author does warn not too be too flexible as the
jack of all trades is the master of none. The closing point is one that is applicable
to most walks of life; preparation, training, research into past wars and
studying the theories will lead to success.
I can recommend The Journal of Military Operations as not only is it free to access but it also contains good articles written with present day operations in mind.
Wednesday, 14 November 2012
The Great War
Recently there has been an increase in articles in the
national press relating to the Great War. With just under two years left until
the centenary of the outbreak of war this is understandable. The build up is
going to result in an renewed interest and hopefully a desire to understand the
battles of the Great War past the tired and worn stereotype of lions led by donkeys.
There are already a number of authors who hold this
revisionist view and their number is growing especially among academic circles.
I believe this will lead to a far better understanding of the British “Tommie”
of 1914-18, what motivated him, what he was equipped with, how he was trained
and importantly how he was commanded and controlled once in battle.
The battles of Mons
and Le Cateau followed by the rearguard actions as the BEF retreated would see
the BEF tested to its limits both at an individual and command level. It
provides an interesting contrast to the image of mud and trenches and was one
of the last times in the war that the artillery would be deployed in the
traditional sense and firing over open sights at the enemy.
Some books I would recommend are:
Richard Holmes – Riding the Retreat. This book is as much a
battlefield tour as it is a history of the opening actions and retreat. Filled
with plenty of great accounts and told in the usual highly readable style of
Richard Holmes.
John Terraine – Mons :
The Retreat to Victory. Again another book by a respected author and one that I
admittedly haven’t read in a few years but was a very good account of the
actions.
This months Military History Monthly has an interesting
article on Mons
as well.
Photo source - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/6461635/Poppy-Appeal-pinning-down-poppy-etiquette.html
Photo source - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/6461635/Poppy-Appeal-pinning-down-poppy-etiquette.html
Tuesday, 15 May 2012
Own Goal
Well the Argentinean Olympic advert that became news last
week has proved to be a bit of an own goal. As ever Kirchner championed this
latest swipe at British sovereignty over the islands. As ever laying claim to the islands with politically charged stunts. It does finish with a statement about veterans of the conflict, but fails to mention that it was a conflict that Argentina started. As provocative as the
advert is, it now looks like the athlete (Fernando Zylberberg) who features in
it, has been deselected from the Argentine team.
This will be a bit of an embarrassment to Kirchner having
made such a big deal of the advert by endorsing it. It will also be an embarrassment
to the Argentine government as they are always quick to condemn any British
publicity over the islands. Not only that but international politics should be
left out of sport and really goes against everything the Olympics stands for. Thankfully
even the Argentine Olympic Committee has distanced itself from the advert.
With the Olympics drawing ever closer it will be interesting
to see what else the Argentine government can come up with to highlight their
dispute over the sovereignty of the islands.
Wednesday, 2 May 2012
Kabul 2012
April saw the deadly attacks on Kabul from within the city. These attacks
were significant as it showed not only the vulnerability of the city but also
the ability of the reinvigorated Taliban to strike where they please.
While the attacks may not have caused an enormous amount of
physical damage, the attacks were a spectacular PR victory for the Taliban. The
PR success was then made all the greater by President Karzai declaring it a
failure on the part of NATO intelligence, once more showing Karzai to be
playing at political point scoring.
It is true that this was a failure on the part of NATO to
prevent these attacks, however it must be remembered that Afghan forces should
also be able to detect and stop such attacks occurring as it is not long until
the NATO forces that Karzai likes to criticize so much withdraw from the
country.
While people may like to make comparisons with the American
involvement in Vietnam ,
the Taleban are unlikely to achieve a military victory over the coalition forces.
Once the coalition forces have withdrawn from the country and there are only
“advisors” left then it might be a different matter. This is where American
involvement may become a little closer to the Vietnam comparison and the Taliban
will no doubt be prepared to bleed American and Afghan forces until the final
American forces depart from the country. If the Taliban are then able to take
on and defeat Afghan government forces then it will add a further perceived
“cut and run” laurel to the American reputation.
That is not to say that it is inevitable that the Taliban
will emerge as the victors. There are many factors that could prevent that
including some of the powerful tribal forces of various warlods switching sides
once the foreign forces have left.
It will be interesting over the coming weeks to see if there
are further “spectacular” attacks carried out and claimed by the Taliban. It
will also be interesting to see the long term implications on the drawdown of
forces and the timetable for the exit.
Photo source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/blog/2012/apr/15/kabul-attacks-live-updates
Photo source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/blog/2012/apr/15/kabul-attacks-live-updates
Monday, 12 March 2012
One Step Forward, Two Steps Back
The coalition plans for withdrawal suffered another setback
this weekend at the hands of a lone US Staff Sergeant. The news of the horrific
killings have unsurprisingly generated plenty of coverage in the papers over
the last two days. As many commentators have been quick to point out, this is
yet another embarrassing moment for US commanders coming at a time when
the outrage over the burning of copies of the Koran had started to dissipate.
Many commentators (at least in the UK ) have also been quick to point
out that there has not been a wave of protests or attacks against coalition
troops in response to the killings, so far. What then is likely to occur over the next
few days and weeks.
It will be interesting to see if any protests do occur as a
result of the horrific and cold blooded actions of the lone gunman. However
with the initial 48 hours passing it might be a case that many Afghans have
become resigned to living life in a hostile environment where outsiders are
generally unwelcome and death and injury comes from either insurgent activity (IEDs
or reprisal etc) or from coalition activity (“collateral” damage). There is
also the tribal element at play, the deaths occurred in the South of the
country which is Pashtun. Despite and almost because of the near endless
conflict that Afghanistan
has witnessed, there is little national identity. Instead Tribal identity can
take precedence over national identity.
The Taleban were quick to try and seize the narrative of the
events and issue declarations condemning the coalition forces as “savages” out
to spill the blood of innocent Afghans. The Taleban have vowed to avenge these
killings through attack on coalition forces.
Interestingly, this will be business as usual for the
Taleban; but by making the statement and seizing the narrative of the event
they appear to be doing something for the good of the Afghan people.
The press will spin the story out as long as it sells and
will seek to use the attack as justification that our forces should no longer
be in Afghanistan .
Importantly the coverage the attacks receive will throw into the spotlight the ongoing
discussions around the withdrawal of UK
and US forces from Afghanistan . As
one commentator pointed out, this could be a moment where Afghan politicians
try and hold foreign forces accountable for their actions. There are already
calls for the perpetrator to face justice in Afghanistan
(something that the US
is unlikely to acquiesce to).
Ultimately I believe that not a lot (aside from the usual
levels of violence) will occur as a direct result following this attack. There
will undoubtedly be attacks which the Taleban will claim are in retaliation to
this event; but in all likelihood would have occurred anyway just in
retaliation to something else.
The biggest impact these attacks will have is on the families
of the victims and on the withdrawal plans. The timings of the withdrawals may
not change but there will certainly be further conditions placed on the coalition
troops staying in Afghanistan .
Photo source: (AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd) (Credit: AP) http://www.salon.com/2010/07/25/wikileaks_4/
Tuesday, 6 March 2012
Market Garden
Operation Market Garden has been the subject of many books,
TV programmes and films; but what makes Market Garden so interesting.
A leading factor is that it is often viewed as a doomed
operation from the start. An operation that was flawed in every aspect; and
plays up to the image of the British forces conducting business as usual rather
than the dash that was required.
There are plenty of sources out there covering Market Garden
from well known films such as “A Bridge Too Far” and “Band of Brothers” to
written accounts of the battle either covering a small part of the battle (such
as the battle for Arnhem itself) or taking a wider look at the entirety of
operation. There are also plenty of first hand accounts and the tales of the
brave Red Devils holding on for much longer than was expected against far
greater odds, makes for exciting reading and viewing.
This makes researching Market Garden not only accessible but
also very interesting as there are many different angles to look at. When
researching Market Garden I found Robert Kershaw’s “It Never Snows in
September” very interesting as it covered the German perspective of the battle,
which as I do not speak or read German proved very useful.
The National Archives also has a vast amount of unit War
Diaries that can be easily accessed and can contain some often overlooked
“quirks” of the operation. One such “quirk” involved the Dutch village of Oss and the supply dump located there
(this is going to be the subject of a blog post in April).
Finally Market Garden involved airpower (or lack of at
crucial moments), plenty of tanks and artillery and not to forget the infantry
(including British, American and Polish airborne forces as well as German
paratroops opposing them). This level of combined arms required a huge planning
and logistical arrangement. This alone provides a lot of primary sources that
are available to view at the National Archives and can really give an insight
into how certain departments and arms of service assess priorities.
Thursday, 1 March 2012
Sabre Rattling
The Falkland Islands (or
Las Malvinas as the Argentinians like to refer to then) are cause for further
concern this year. Argentina
wants to push the issue over sovereignty of the Islands
as much as it can. The question is how far will they go this time?
I think it is a safe bet that there will not be a full scale
conflict over the Falkland Islands and if there was it is unlikely to be a repeat of
1982. The justification for this view is simple; we live in a very different
world today than 30 years ago. Both countries face different challenges in the
next few years and in the case of Argentina have a more benign government.
However with this being said, Argentina (President Kirchner) seems
unwilling to simply back down from the issue. It has been said that Kirchner
has little to lose and a lot to gain by forcing the issue.
It is highly likely that we will see a continuation of the rhetoric
and economic warfare on the part of Argentina
and its South American allies against both the Falklands and Britain . This
is certainly how it seems to be playing out so far, a lot of tough talk
followed by calls for the boycott of British goods and the prevention of cruise
ships that have visited the Falklands from
docking in Argentinean ports.
Thankfully the UK
government is not rising to the bait and instead maintaining the same stance
that it has held for a long time; that should the population of the Falkland Islands wish to discuss sovereignty of the
island then it will not be stopped. No amount of name calling or tantrums will
change that and Argentina
runs the risk of losing what international support it has.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





